YouTube, a cornucopia of informational videos, alternative news sources, and real-time footage of fantastic encounters too outrageous to believe. Or are they? Three friends form the channel Skeptic Soup to debunk sensational claims, but when a first-hand account involving a missing boy takes them to the wilds of Canada, what they find may—or may not—align with their personal beliefs.

Will they survive their foray into the field? Or worse, will they have to eat their words?